Icy Sidewalks Start Early: Your Rights in a Michigan Fall Slip-and-Fall

Michigan’s First Frost Brings Early Risks

Michigan’s autumn mornings can turn treacherous in an instant. What begins as a crisp, colorful fall day can quickly shift overnight when temperatures dip below freezing. By late October, the first frosts often arrive, coating sidewalks, porches, and driveways with an invisible layer of ice — long before snowplows and salt trucks are ready for the season.

For many Michiganders, this early freeze catches them off guard. You step outside to grab the paper, take the dog for a walk, or head to work — and suddenly, your foot slips on what looked like a harmless patch of pavement. In just seconds, a routine morning can turn into a painful fall, a hospital visit, and weeks of recovery.

But when these early-season slip-and-falls occur, who is responsible for the unsafe conditions?

That question falls under Michigan premises liability law, which determines when a property owner, landlord, or business can be held accountable for failing to keep their property safe. Whether it’s a cracked sidewalk, untreated black ice, or an unshoveled apartment walkway, these hazards can create dangerous — and preventable — situations.

At Liss, Shapero & Mitnick, our Berkley-based injury lawyers have helped Michigan residents recover from slip-and-fall injuries for more than 25 years. We understand how complex these cases can be, especially when early freezes make it unclear who’s at fault. Our mission is simple: protect the rights of injured individuals and ensure negligent property owners are held accountable.

Michigan’s “Open and Obvious” Rule Is Changing

For decades, Michigan law made it difficult for slip-and-fall victims to win their cases. Under the old “open and obvious” rule, property owners were often not liable for hazards that a “reasonable person” could have seen and avoided — even if the condition was dangerous.

That meant if ice was visible, a court could dismiss the case, reasoning that the victim should have been more careful. This interpretation unfairly favored property owners and left many injured individuals without recourse.

However, in 2023, the Michigan Supreme Court’s decision in Kandil-Elsayed v. F & E Oil, Inc. significantly limited the use of the open and obvious defense. The Court ruled that property owners can still be held liable if they failed to take reasonable steps to protect visitors — even when a hazard is visible.

This decision marks a major shift in Michigan slip-and-fall law. It recognizes that visibility alone doesn’t excuse negligence. The focus is now on foreseeability, safety, and reasonable care, not just whether a person “should have seen” the danger.

Here’s what this means for you:

• Victims have stronger claims for injuries caused by black ice, shaded walkways, or unavoidable routes — areas where ice may not be safely avoidable.
• Property owners must take proactive measures to clear, salt, or warn visitors about icy conditions, especially in high-traffic areas.
• For example, if a tenant slips on unshoveled apartment steps, that situation — once dismissed under the old rule — may now be legally actionable.

The bottom line? Don’t assume you have no case just because the ice was “visible.” An experienced icy sidewalk fall lawyer in Michigan, like the team at Liss, Shapero & Mitnick, can evaluate your situation under the new legal standard and help you pursue compensation for your injuries.

Landlord and Municipal Duties to Prevent Ice Injuries

Understanding who’s responsible for clearing ice depends on the property type and location. Under Michigan law, different parties may share responsibility for maintaining safe walkways:

• Homeowners are generally required to keep their sidewalks, driveways, and entryways safe for guests and delivery workers. Failing to shovel, salt, or warn about ice can lead to liability if someone slips and falls.
• Landlords have a heightened legal duty under Michigan housing codes to remove ice from common areas, stairs, and parking lots. They must maintain these shared spaces in a reasonably safe condition for tenants and visitors.
• Municipalities (like Berkley, Royal Oak, and Ferndale) often have ordinances requiring snow and ice removal within a certain time after a freeze or snowfall — sometimes as short as 24 hours. Failure to comply can result in fines and potential civil liability if an injury occurs.

These laws mean that property owners can’t ignore icy conditions just because “winter hasn’t officially started.” Early freezes are predictable — and so is the duty to prevent them from causing harm.

Commercial properties and businesses owe an even higher duty of care, since they invite customers onto their premises. They must regularly inspect entryways and sidewalks, salt icy patches, and post warning signs when needed.

For example:

• A store owner who fails to salt the front walkway overnight may be liable when a customer slips the next morning.
• A landlord who ignores repeated complaints about an icy stairwell could be held responsible when a tenant fractures an ankle.

Ultimately, liability depends on who had control and responsibility for maintaining the area where the fall occurred. A skilled premises liability attorney can help determine which party — or parties — should be held accountable under Michigan law.

Notice, Evidence, and the Importance of Photos

In Michigan, early-morning ice can melt or refreeze within hours — and with it, the most important proof of your injury’s cause can disappear. Preserving evidence right after a fall is critical to protecting your rights and building a strong case.

If you or someone you love slips on an icy surface, take action immediately:

• Photograph everything – Take clear, close-up photos of the ice patch, surrounding walkway, and nearby lighting or shadows. Include wider shots that show the property layout and any missing warning signs.
• Document your clothing and footwear – Insurance companies often try to blame victims by questioning their shoes or attire. Photos of what you were wearing help eliminate that argument.
• Record the time and weather conditions – Note the date, exact time, temperature, and visibility. Early freezes and shade patterns can help prove that the ice was not obvious or easily avoidable.
• Notify the property owner or manager – File a written report or send an email as soon as possible. This helps preserve your claim and establishes that the owner had notice of the hazard.
• Get witness contact information – If anyone saw your fall or the conditions leading up to it, ask for their name and phone number. Their statements can support your version of events.

Under Michigan premises liability law, proving that the property owner knew or should have known about the dangerous condition is key to establishing negligence. Evidence such as weather reports, maintenance logs, or surveillance footage can show how long the ice existed and whether it should have been treated.

A quick smartphone photo or brief written notice may seem simple, but it can be the difference between a denied claim and a successful recovery. Time-stamped photos and documented notice can make or break your case.

The Medical Timeline: Why Prompt Care Matters

After a fall, you may feel sore but think you’ll recover on your own. Unfortunately, many slip-and-fall injuries — especially those caused by hard impacts on ice — don’t reveal their full extent right away. Back injuries, concussions, or fractures may develop or worsen over the following days.

That’s why immediate medical attention is critical. Not only does it protect your health, but it also creates an official record that ties your injuries directly to the fall. Hospitals and urgent care providers document symptoms, timing, and diagnosis — vital details that insurers and attorneys rely on when evaluating your claim.

Insurance companies often argue that a delay in treatment means an injury wasn’t serious or was caused by something else. Seeking prompt care prevents that tactic and strengthens your credibility.

To support your case, keep a clear medical record by tracking:

• Emergency room or urgent care reports
• Follow-up appointments with orthopedic doctors or physical therapists
• Prescriptions and pain journals documenting your daily symptoms
• Lost wages or missed work days during recovery

Every detail helps your attorney build a timeline that connects your fall, medical treatment, and financial losses. At Liss, Shapero & Mitnick, we guide clients through this process step by step — ensuring that nothing is overlooked.

Don’t Let the First Freeze Catch You Off Guard

Michigan’s weather doesn’t wait for winter to start causing problems. By late October, black ice can form overnight, catching even the most cautious walkers by surprise. These early freezes often strike before property owners, landlords, or businesses have their salting routines in place — and that’s when the most dangerous slip-and-fall accidents happen.

It’s important to remember that slippery sidewalks aren’t “just accidents.” Under Michigan law, property owners have a clear duty to act responsibly and take reasonable steps to prevent injuries. That means inspecting walkways, clearing ice, and warning visitors about unsafe areas. When they fail to do so, their negligence can — and should — be held accountable.

If you do experience a fall, stay calm, document everything, and seek medical help right away. Taking photos of the scene, keeping weather information, and contacting an attorney early can make all the difference in protecting your rights.

Contact Liss, Shapero & Mitnick Today

If you or someone you love was hurt in a slip-and-fall caused by icy conditions on a sidewalk, driveway, or business entrance, don’t wait for the insurance company to decide what your case is worth. Contact Liss, Shapero & Mitnick — trusted icy sidewalk fall lawyers in Michigan — for the guidance and advocacy you deserve.

📞 Contact Us:
Liss, Shapero & Mitnick
2695 Coolidge Highway
Berkley, MI 48072
Phone: 248-584-1300
Toll-Free: 1-855-LISS-LAW (547-7529)

‍