.svg)
.png)
Open Enrollment and Michigan’s No-Fault Insurance System
It’s that time of year again — Open Enrollment season. From mid-October through early December, Michigan residents review their health insurance options and make decisions that affect their coverage for the year ahead. But if you drive in Michigan, your health plan selection may affect more than just doctor visits and prescriptions — it can also determine how your auto insurance pays out after a car accident.
Michigan’s no-fault insurance system is unique. It ensures that if you’re injured in a car crash, your own insurance covers medical expenses, lost wages, and certain other costs, regardless of who caused the accident. What many drivers don’t realize is that the way your health insurance and auto insurance work together — a process called coordination — can directly impact your benefits, your out-of-pocket costs, and how smoothly your claims are handled.
In short, coordinating your health insurance with your no-fault policy can save you money, but it can also lead to confusion and billing disputes if you don’t fully understand how it works.
At Liss, Shapero & Mitnick, our Berkley-based attorneys have spent decades helping clients across Metro Detroit understand and protect their rights under Michigan’s no-fault system. We believe that informed decisions during Open Enrollment can make all the difference if an accident ever happens.
Coordinated vs. Uncoordinated PIP: What’s the Difference?
Understanding PIP Coverage
Under Michigan’s no-fault system, every driver must carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage. PIP pays for your medical bills, lost wages, and household services if you’re injured in an auto accident — regardless of fault.
When you buy your auto policy, you choose whether to have coordinated or uncoordinated (primary) PIP coverage. The option you select determines which insurance company — your health insurer or your auto insurer — pays first after an accident.
Coordinated PIP
With coordinated PIP, your health insurance is primary for medical expenses related to an auto accident. This means your health plan pays first, and your auto insurer only steps in to cover what’s left — such as deductibles, copays, or services not covered by your health plan.
Pros:
- Typically results in lower auto insurance premiums.
- Can help avoid duplication of coverage if you already have comprehensive health insurance.
Cons:
- Can cause delays or confusion between insurance companies about who should pay.
- You may face out-of-pocket costs if your health plan denies coverage or applies a high deductible.
Uncoordinated (Primary) PIP
With uncoordinated PIP, your auto insurance pays all eligible medical expenses related to the accident, regardless of your health coverage. Your health plan is not involved.
Pros:
- A simplified claims process — fewer disputes or delays.
- Fewer coverage gaps, especially for services not typically covered by health insurance (like in-home attendant care).
Cons:
- Higher auto insurance premiums, since your auto insurer bears full responsibility for medical costs.
Example Comparison
- Example 1: Coordinated Coverage
Jane has coordinated PIP and is injured in a car accident. She goes to the emergency room, and her health insurance pays first. Her plan has a $1,500 deductible, which Jane must pay. Her auto insurer covers that deductible and any remaining expenses related to her injuries. - Example 2: Uncoordinated Coverage
Tom has uncoordinated PIP. After his crash, his auto insurer pays all of his medical bills directly, without going through his health insurance. Tom has no deductibles or copays related to the accident — but he pays a higher annual premium for his policy.
These examples show why understanding your PIP option before a crash happens is so important. The right choice depends on your personal situation, health coverage, and comfort level with managing multiple insurers.
Deductibles, Copays, and Coverage Gaps
No-fault and health insurance policies don’t always align perfectly, and how they interact can affect your out-of-pocket costs.
- With coordinated coverage, your health insurance is in charge first. That means you must pay your plan’s deductible and copays before your auto insurer steps in to cover any leftover bills.
- With uncoordinated coverage, your auto insurer typically pays 100% of your reasonable accident-related medical costs (up to your selected PIP limit), regardless of your health plan’s terms.
Potential Pitfalls to Watch For
- Out-of-Network Providers: If you receive care at a hospital or clinic outside your health plan’s network, your health insurer may deny payment — leaving your auto insurer to dispute or delay coverage.
- Limited Coverage: Some health plans exclude or restrict accident-related care, such as long-term rehabilitation or in-home nursing.
- Coverage Disputes: Patients are often caught between insurers, each claiming the other should pay first. This can delay treatment and lead to unpaid medical bills.
To avoid these headaches, keep detailed documentation — including copies of medical bills, insurance forms, and any correspondence between insurers. If disputes arise, those records can help your attorney resolve the issue quickly and ensure your benefits are paid in full.
Choosing the Right Health Plan During Open Enrollment
Open Enrollment is more than just a time to pick a new health plan—it’s also the perfect opportunity to make sure your health insurance and Michigan no-fault auto policy work together the way you expect. The decisions you make during this period can have a lasting impact on your coverage, your out-of-pocket costs, and how easily you can access medical care after an accident.
If you drive in Michigan, here are some key factors to review before finalizing your health insurance plan:
- Does your health plan include accident coverage?
Not all health insurance policies cover auto-related injuries. Some exclude or severely limit benefits for car accident treatment, especially for long-term rehabilitation or attendant care. - Are your preferred hospitals, doctors, and rehab centers in-network?
Staying within your network can save thousands of dollars in out-of-pocket costs. This is especially important if you have coordinated PIP coverage, since your health insurer pays first. - What are your deductible and out-of-pocket maximums?
A lower deductible health plan may make coordinated coverage a smart choice. If your deductible is high, however, those costs will come out of your pocket before your auto insurer steps in. - Does a family or individual plan make more sense?
If multiple family members drive or regularly ride in your insured vehicles, your choice can affect how medical expenses are covered for everyone after an accident.
The right decision depends on your personal circumstances. Open Enrollment is the ideal time to talk with your insurance agent—or an experienced no-fault attorney—to review how your coverage choices work together.
Common Questions and Misconceptions
If I have great health insurance, do I still need full PIP?
Yes. Even the best health insurance plans often have exclusions or limits for auto accident care. Many do not cover long-term rehabilitation, in-home attendant care, or specialized transportation after a crash—services that PIP often provides. Choosing too low of a PIP limit can leave serious coverage gaps if you’re severely injured.
Will coordinating save me money?
It can. Coordinated PIP coverage usually results in a lower auto insurance premium, but there’s a tradeoff. You might face slower claim processing, more paperwork, or higher out-of-pocket expenses if your health plan applies large deductibles or copays before your auto insurer contributes.
What if my health plan changes next year?
Your coordination choice doesn’t automatically update when your health insurance changes. If you switch jobs or change health plans, it can alter how your PIP coverage works. Always review both your health and auto policies every year during Open Enrollment to ensure they still complement one another.
Protect Yourself During Open Enrollment
As Open Enrollment begins, take time to do more than just pick a new health plan — make sure you understand how it fits with your Michigan no-fault auto insurance. Coordinating your health and auto coverage can save you money in premiums, but it also introduces added complexity. If you don’t know which insurer pays first, or what happens when your coverage changes, you could face delays, denied bills, or unexpected expenses after an accident.
Now is the time to review your PIP coverage, compare your deductibles, and verify that your health plan actually includes auto accident benefits. Keep clear records, ask questions, and don’t wait until a crash happens to discover how your policies work together.
At Liss, Shapero & Mitnick, we’re not just here when things go wrong — we’re here to help you make informed decisions before they do. Our attorneys are proud to guide Michigan families through these complex systems with the same professionalism and compassion that define every case we take. Because being proactive today can protect your rights and your financial security tomorrow.
If you have questions about how to coordinate health insurance with Michigan no-fault, or if you’ve experienced a coverage dispute after a crash, contact Liss, Shapero & Mitnick for a free, no-obligation consultation. Our experienced attorneys can explain your rights, help resolve insurance issues, and make sure you receive every benefit you’re entitled to under Michigan law.
📍 2695 Coolidge Highway, Berkley, MI 48072
📞 248-584-1300 | Toll-Free: 1-855-LISS-LAW (547-7529)
💻 www.lsmlawyers.com